How Should Association Officers Protect the Accounts That Hold Member Money?
Why are association accounts so hard to protect?
Because they change hands every year. A new treasurer gets elected, and the old one passes along the club email, the bank login, the payment account and the Facebook page, usually with the passwords written on a sticky note or in an email that's still sitting in somebody's inbox.
Nobody's doing anything wrong there. That's just how volunteer organizations work. But it means the same password might be known by five or six people after a few years, some of whom aren't involved anymore.
We wrote about the other side of this problem, how easy it is for a scammer to pretend to be an association, in Why Are Horse Associations So Easy for Scammers to Impersonate? This post is about the accounts themselves.
Which accounts matter most?
Start with anything that can move money or reset other passwords.
The club email. This is the big one. Whoever controls the club email can usually reset the password on everything else the club owns.
The bank and any payment accounts. Wherever member dues, entry fees, sponsor money or auction payments land.
The website and auction admin logins. These control what your members see and where they're told to send money.
The Facebook page. Getting a hijacked page back is a long, miserable process.
Should every officer have their own login?
Wherever the service allows it, yes. That's the single biggest improvement most associations can make.
Most banks let an organization add more than one person, each with their own login and their own level of access. Facebook pages let you add people as admins under their own personal accounts. Google and Microsoft accounts can hold more than one passkey, so each officer can add their own. And for the website and auction admin, we can help you get each officer set up properly, so nobody's passing around one shared login.
When everybody has their own login, you can take one person off without changing anything for everybody else.
Where do passkeys fit in?
A passkey lets you sign in with your face, fingerprint or phone PIN instead of a password, and it only works on the real website it was made for. So a fake login page can't use it. (We explained how they work in more detail in our post on passkeys this month.)
For an association, the nice part is that each officer's passkey lives on their own phone. There's no password to write on a sticky note, and when an officer's term is up, you remove their passkey from the account and they're out.
What should happen when officers change?
Make it part of the officer handoff, the same as passing along the checkbook. Here's a simple list.
- Remove the outgoing officer's own logins and passkeys from every account.
- Change any password that was shared, even if you trust everybody involved.
- Check the recovery email and phone number on each account. They should belong to the club, not to someone who left three years ago.
- Let us know so we can update the website and auction admin logins.
- Remind members, in writing, how the club takes money and that you'll never email them a new place to send it.
Frequently asked questions
Is it OK for officers to share one password?
It works, and lots of clubs do it. The trouble is you can never take one person off without changing it for everybody, so in practice it rarely gets changed. Separate logins fix that.
What if a former officer still has access?
Don't take it personally and don't make it awkward. Just change the shared passwords, remove their personal access, and check the recovery email and phone on each account. It's housekeeping, not an accusation.
What should the club email address be?
Ideally one on the club's own domain name, like treasurer@ your club's website address, that stays with the office no matter who holds it. A personal Gmail address leaves with the person.
Do passkeys work on an account several people use?
On services that allow more than one passkey per account, like Google and Microsoft, each person can add their own. Where that's not available, separate logins for each officer are the better answer.
Let's talk
If your association has new officers coming in and you'd like the website and auction logins cleaned up, call us at 979-217-1544. That's the easy part, and we're glad to do it.
Tom Bruch has built websites since 1998 and is the owner of Big Sky Internet Design.
